The Seven Month European Journey ends with mixed feelings.

Celtic exited Europe last night with a 1-0 defeat to Valencia in the Mestalla.

There was little surprise. Few if any held out any genuine hope of our progression last night after a pretty disastrous 2-0 home defeat at Celtic park eight days ago.

But in fairness, we did gain a fair amount of redemption for our disappointing performance in the home leg. Last night we approached the game with some belief, quite a lot of it actually and a plan. Unlike the first tie, we showed we are a capable passing team with decent game management and for most of the first half controlled the ball and looked the more likely to score. On 37 mins though Jeremy Toljan got his second yellow card and any flickering hopes of an unlikely comeback were more or less extinguished. We came under the cosh for the rest of the half and it took some fine saves from Scott Bain, who is now really starting to look the real deal, to prevent our hosts from scoring and the floodgates from opening.

Image result for valencia 1-0 celtic scott bain
Bain looks the part.

In the second half, Bain again was called into action though we began to grow into it again and Kristofer Ajer miscued a header from a freekick into the box that could have put us right back in it and the cat really amongst the pigeons.  Alas, it went high, wide and handsome.

Substitute Kevin Gaimero tapped in the only goal on 70 minutes and that was that but we kept battling to the end determined to make sure we didn’t fall to an undeserved heavy defeat and when the whistle went we departed the continental stage at the Last 32 round with our heads held high.

In truth, we didn’t create much in the way of clear cut chances. Oliver Burke was deployed up front by himself in the first half and though his pace hurt the Spaniards his lack of a first touch certainly didn’t. Jonny Hayes had a good far post chance but scooped his effort over the bar. In the second half, James Forrest was inexplicably moved into the middle as the lone striker whilst Odsonne Edouard and Timothy Weah looked on from the bench most likely perplexed. Why French Eddy wasn’t deployed from the start with Burke out wide in his natural position only Brendan knows but a combination of lacking faith in his own convictions as well as just overrating Burke’s abilities as a finisher are the leading candidates.

Personally, I thought it was a missed opportunity last night. Valencia looked a little bereft and the home fans were on their back pretty quickly. Our passing game was much sharper with Mcgregor and Brown in particular far better than they had been at Celtic Park. With an actual striker on who knows but I guess that’s neither here nor there because Toljan getting his marching orders pretty much torpedoed our hopes anyway. The German full-back was naive but at the same time, it was the sort of sending off you get against bigger name opposition on the continent that you just know the ref wouldn’t give against them. He wasn’t shy to flash yellow cards at us all night whilst giving out warnings to the men in white shirts for identical fouls. But it’s always been that way in Europe and will never change.

Image result for valencia 1-0 celtic
No chance he’s doing that to the number 5 in white.

Looking back we’ve played a mammoth 16 games in European competition this season. That’s far more than the nine we played to win the European Cup in 1967 or even the 15 we played in the 2002/2003 season when we reached the UEFA Cup final after a Champions League play-off defeat. So the most in one season in our history. Of those 16 ties, we won seven, drew three and lost six. A mixed bag.

The highlight was undoubtedly the 2-1 home win against RB Leipzig at Celtic Park on a night where we defeated a team who have been sitting in fourth spot in the Bundesliga all season.

The lows were…….well take your pick basically. The Champions League elimination to Athens, drawing away in Suduva, being bowled over so easily away to Salzburg and in Leipzig or the anticlimactic displays at home to Salzburg and Valencia.

Scottish football as a whole has also seen its stock risen with the Scottish league’s coefficient rising from 25 to 20 due to this season displays. A draw last night would have actually nudged Scotland slightly ahead of Serbia in 19th spot so, on the whole, it’s been a beneficial season for everyone with not just Celtic actually delivering some points for once.

Brendan’s European record still isn’t great. 16 wins from 40 games with six draws and 18 losses isn’t horrific but could and should be better. With only 12 wins from 32 European ties Neil Lennon’s record was actually worse but his win column included the victory over Barcelona and also saw us progress to the Champions League Last 16 with a Scottish record for a club from these shores in the Champions League of 10 points, something which is unlikely to be repeated any time soon if at all.

Gordan Strachan’s also wasn’t great either with only eight wins from 26 but those were, of course, the days when we hardly played any qualifiers and, as a result, minnows, and were generally straight in with the big boys. He also took us to glory nights against Manchester Utd (1-0), AC Milan (2-1), Benfica (3-0), Donetsk (2-1) and back to back Champions League Last 16 qualifications which once again will unlikely happen in the foreseeable future.

He is of course way off Martin ONeill’s ledger which includes an incredible 26 wins in European competition from 53 European ties and had far too many glory nights to mention with the greatest of his achievements being leading us to our first major European final in  33 years.

Anyway, this seasons is done and playing in Europe after Christmas is no mean feat. That’s only the eight-time we’ve done it in the past 39 years which should put our European expectations into some kind of perspective.  That and the fact that Kevin Gaimero who came on as a sub to score against us last night has won the competition we were playing in an incredible four times which shows you what we are up against.

Onwards and upwards domestically starting with a revitalised Motherwell on Sunday.

 

Europa League preview: Rosenborg vs Celtic – It’s do or die……again!

On Thursday night Celtic will travel to Trondheim for the third time in nearly 16 months and the second time in less than four months to take on Norwegian Champions Rosenborg.

I’ve used this title before but it really is apt. It most definitely is ‘do or die’ as anything but a win on Thursday will see us relying on results elsewhere and no longer having our destiny in our own hands in regards to qualifying for the Europa League knockout stages and seeing European football post-Christmas.

There are various permutations to going through but I’ll look at those later on in the article. For now, I’m going to concentrate on our opposition.

As stated, in the beginning, we know them well. Almost too well. Indeed when I heard we’d been drawn with them in the group stages I was, to say the least, a little underwhelmed considering how many times we’ve played them recently. We do of course have a pretty good record against them having not lost one of our last five encounters with them which have seen us beat them three times and draw twice. One of those wins was also at their home ground in Trondheim when James Forrest smashed in a solitary winner against them in August of 2017. Overall we have a 5-1 lead in terms of goals as well with the two draws both ending goalless.

They have just wrapped up their fourth consecutive Norwegian title –  which is a record 26th overall – after completing the season with 19 wins from 30 games with seven draws and only four defeats.

Champions of Norway again. 

Since playing us last on the 20th of September they have played 10 domestic matches – eight in the league and two in the cup – and have lost only one which was a 1-0 defeat in the league to eventual runners-up Molde. They have however also drawn three games, have only scored 15 goals and have conceded seven in that time.

Their main goal scoring threats are veteran strike pair Alexander Søderlund and the mercurial Nicklas Bendtner. They have scored 24 goals between them this season though only four in Europe. Bendtner though hasn’t seen much football in recent weeks which is something he’ll have to get used to as he’s just been convicted of assaulting a taxi driver. He’s due to return to his native Denmark to serve a 50-day jail term at an as of yet undetermined date.  In recent months their veteran midfielder Mike Jensen and young Nigerian forward Samuel Adegbenro have stepped up to the plate with some important goals though neither are in double figures.

Image result for nicklas bendtner
Bad boy Nicky outside court.

In the Europa League groups stages this term, their record has been pretty woeful having lost all four matches thus far conceding 12 and scoring only three. Last time out they entrained Red Bull Salzburg and were ripped apart 5-2, scoring both of their goals when already down 4-0. This came on the back of a 3-0 hiding in Salzburg and to be honest their record in the Europa League group stages full stop pretty awful as they have only recorded three wins in their last 22 and haven’t played in Europe beyond Christmas this century.

All that being said we struggled to break them down in the home leg 10 weeks ago and it took a late Leigh Griffiths header to gain the victory. We also really struggled away against them in Trondheim back on August 1st in a stale 0-0 game where we only created one real chance.

But let’s also put our last two encounters against them into context. Backing August that was the second leg of a tie in which we were already 3-1 up from the home leg so it was natural that we would defend what we had and in the end we got the job done. The Norwegians were the better team on the night but they really didn’t create much and on reflection at least it was a nervy but ultimately pretty professional job.

In the September game, we still dominated and us struggling to break them down was a general issue at the time. Indeed the following weekend we lost 2-1 at Kilmarnock and as the talk of crisis loomed we began to get our arses into gear and subsequently have gone on a nine-game unbeaten domestic run with eight wins scoring 28 goals in the process and conceding only two. Europe has of course been a different story but after disappointing away performances to Salzburg and Leipzig we produced a stunning 2-1 win against the Germans on matchday four to keep our hopes of qualification well and truly alive.

The last time we went to Trondheim needing to win was in August 2017 during a Champions League qualifier. Having drawn the first leg 0-0 at home the pressure was all on us to produce and produce we did as we dominated the game with 63% possession of the ball. As mentioned earlier James Forrest scored on 69 minutes and not long after raced through on goal to score number two but fluffed his lines. It was one of the most comfortable nights I can remember Celtic having on the road against good opposition in Europe and we simply have to replicate it tomorrow evening.

Tom Rogic will be back and Filipe Benkovic will hopefully make a rare European away start for us also. We missed both badly the last time we ventured abroad and having them back in is a huge plus point.

Image result for filip benkovic
Benkovic needs to bring the power tomorrow night.

Interestingly both clubs have major cup finals on the Sunday following the match. For Celtic, it’s a chance to win seven consecutive major trophies in the League Cup final against Aberdeen whereas for Rosenborg it’s a chance to a secure a rare domestic treble as they go up against Strømsgodset– the team that Ronny Deila came from – in the Norwegian Football Cup final.

I wonder how much that will play into their thinking? Winger Pål André Helland is already in a buoyant mood comparing their title victory to a penis extension and manager Rini Coolen admitted that despite the upcoming tie against Celtic he allowed his players to go out and party after receiving the league trophy on Sunday.

Despite losing all four matches thus far in the group stages incredibly they still could technically make it to the last 32. They would need to beat us by two goals or more and then hope Leipzig succumbed to Salzburg before then going to Germany on matchday six requiring to beat their hosts by three goals or more whilst hoping that Salzburg defeated us. So it’s to say the very least a long shot and perhaps with that in mind players may be more focused on the big domestic cup match three days later. Some online Celtic sources seem to believe that they could even rest half of their usual starting eleven but what the actual basis for this claim outside of sheer conjecture is anyone’s guess.

Of course our own cup final is pretty important too but I’d say it’s trumped by staying in Europe beyond Christmas.

As for the rest of the permutations we basically need Salzburg to beat Leipzig which would see them qualify as group winners with a game to spare and if we beat Rosenborg we’d only require a point against the Austrians at home in the final group match to secure qualification.

A draw between the two Red Bull sides would also be pretty good news as we’d then face a likely depleted Salzburg side – owing to them having already won the group – in the final match requiring a win unless Leipzig somehow drew or lost against Rosenborg.

Defeat for us and Leipzig win then it’s over. A draw and Leipzig win and it’s as good as over. In fact, a draw for Leipzig and we lose and you’re still clutching at straws. So really we need to win and that’s all there is to it.

But here comes the back down to earth with a bump bit and it’s our away form in Europe. I know it sounds like a broken record pointing it out but it is awful. We haven’t won any of our last five which indeed includes trips to face Rosenborg as well as away to Suduva in the footballing hotbed that is Lithuania. We’ve also only won two of our last 11 away. I could extend the record even further back under Brendan and it shows only four wins in 19. Do you want to hear the goals for and against on the road in Europe too? Na. Me neither. Safe to say it’s eye-watering stuff.

There’s no doubt we struggle badly on the road but maybe on Brendan’s 20th sojourn to the continent we can get arguably his biggest win yet. And a hungover weakened Rosenborg team with one eye on their national cup final on Sunday would definitely help.

On a final note, I’ve just seen the odds for the Salzburg vs Leipzig game. The Austrians despite being group leaders with four wins out of four as well as being undefeated in all competitions this season which has seen them record 22 wins and four draws are somehow underdogs for a home tie against a team they beat 3-2 away in the group stage opener. RB Leipzig start as 4/5 favourites with the home team as 3/1 outsiders. Mmmmmm. That does seem a bit iffy. Is a possible carve up in the offing between two teams with almost identical names and badges? Surely not.

Anyway, we have our destiny in our own hands. Let’s hope we take it with both.

 

Post-match analysis: Red Bull Leipzig 2 – 0 Celtic. More misery on the road and rumours off the pitch abound!

A depleted Celtic side were easily dismissed by a more or less second string Red Bull Leipzig.

For 30 mins Celtic looked okay and Odsonne Edouard nearly even scored but thereafter it was the usual as we were battered senseless in the last 15 mins of the half conceding two goals and it could have been more.

In the second half, Celtic played to keep the score down looking passive and content with it staying at two-zip. Leipzig accommodated us by and large barring a Konrad Laimer run where he skinned half of our team whilst running from midfield before shooting just past the post and a moment when Augustin cracked a long-range shot off of the same stick.

Ntcham broke through on goal late and if he’d passed to his right to McGregor it was a certain goal but he went for glory and cannoned it off the keeper’s legs. Even if it had gone in there is little to no chance that we’d have equalised as the Germans would have just switched on again.

Right from the off all looked lost as we were without the suspended James Forrest, injured Scott Brown and in the days leading up to the match, Tom Rogic and Filipe Benkovic were also ruled out. Added to that Leigh Griffiths still isn’t available and Mikel Lustig was deemed not fit enough to start.

This meant starts for forgotten men Cristian Gamboa and Eboue Kouassi as well as the rarely seen Lewis Morgan and serial bench warmer Ryan Christie.

All that combined with our long-standing, pretty atrocious away record on the content meant that our chances were pretty much slim and none and slim had just left town.

Leipzig themselves were without their injured midfield playmaker Emil Forsberg as well as star striking duo Timo Werner and Yussuf Poulsen who were rested on the bench but still had far more firepower on the pitch.

Of course, we helped them with an awful attempt at a clearance from Kouassi resulting in a fresh air miss so bad it also confused Boyata whose own attempt also missed and it fell to Matheus Cunha who couldn’t believe how much time he had to control it and lash it home.

The second saw Marcelo Saracchi dart down the wing after a wild suicide sliding tackle from Gamboa was skipped over with ease and his resulting cross saw another woeful attempt by Kouassi to clear once again befuddle Boyata and resulted in Bruma lashing it home.

Image result for celtic fc red bull leipzig
A familiar sight on the continent as our players trudge back to the centre circle after conceding another goal. 

It really was comical stuff. Kouassi had a blinder in just how bad he was though incredibly John Hartson labelled him as one of our better players at halftime. I actually kept an eye on him and he was passive throughout with his shoulders dipped and looked lost. Basically a carbon copy of his display earlier in the season against Hearts.

Boyata was also awful in the centre of defence. In the second half, he needlessly gave the ball away on numerous occasions, something he’s well known for, and was left in the wake of the rampaging Laimer when he nearly scored which saw a pretty pathetic attempt by Boyata to stop him.

That aside just about everyone in a Celtic jersey struggled with McGregor, in particular, going missing for much of the game.

It’s really all we’ve come to expect away in Europe under Brendan. Nothing changes tactically and his record now reads 4 wins from 19 away games with 10 defeats and an incredible 38 goals conceded.

We can’t keep a clean sheet away from home against anything resembling quality from the continent and outside of Edouard don’t to appear to have much of a goal threat on the road either.

The loss of some of our best players was definitely a factor and was felt sorely but it somewhat negated by Leipzig resting so many of their top performers yet still looking streets ahead.

The mistakes at the back happen time and again and the players brought in are clearly not good enough. Not only that but most are also Brendan’s signings.

Tactically we are way too open and the moment we concede panic sets in and our shape collapses.

Leipzig visit Glasgow in a fortnight and it literally is a must-win game. If we lose and Salzburg win in Norway as expected then we are out. That’s right we’ll be out with two games still to go from Europe’s second-tier competition. That’s the same competition where Rangers have gone unbeaten in 11 straight games so there really are no excuses.

Inevitably in the fallout, more rumours have surfaced about Brendan’s relationship with the board which seems to be par for the course after we record a negative result.

One of the main fuels to the fire was this tweet by BBC correspondent and self-confessed Rangers fanatic Richard Wilson:

IMG-20181026-WA0002

If there’s any truth in this then next week should be interesting. I mean what else could ‘serious upheaval’ mean other than heads rolling and whose heads would they be?

Thes semi-final of the League Cup on Sunday against Hearts now takes on even more importance as a negative result will likely lead to further rumours of things coming to a head.

There seems to be an attitude prevalent amongst Celtic fans that Sunday was the priority which I found a bit incredible considering Europe is where we want to be but maybe shows the mentality that has crept in in recent years. That being that Europe is perceived as a pipe dream where making any significant progress is fanciable and we are almost willing fodder for the big clubs.

Anyway onto Hampden we go and on and off the pitch I think we can expect some fireworks in the coming days. Should be interesting at least.